Archive for September, 2009
New Professionalism Roundup
Wednesday, September 23rd, 2009Is Summary Justice OK with White People?
Wednesday, September 23rd, 2009This is why it is so important for prosecutors to select an all-white jury, such as the one that tried Esteban Carpio (even though Providence, Rhode Island is over 50% Black and Latino). By getting an all-white jury AND favorable evidentiary decisions from the judge, prosecutors are more like (practically guaranteed) to get a conviction, regardless of the atrocities that police are shown to have committed during the arrest and questioning.
Of course many or most white people will disagree with what I've said here, but they'll also agree that if police beat or electrically shocked an arrestee, then the arrestee "probably got what he deserved". And white juries are unwilling to convict or punish police for their behavior when they believe that the defendant/victim "probably got what he deserved."
What this means is that many or most white people are willing to accept and support summary justice and pre-trial extrajudicial punishment of prisoners as well as a type of informal double jeopardy, in which arrestees for punished once by police at the time of arrest then a second time by the judge after a conviction.
When "justice" works this way, I'm not sure what distinguishes the United States from many other countries. I personally believe that the right to be tried by a jury or judge before punishment is meted out is a more fundamental and important right than the right to bear firearms. Most white people would strongly disagree with me, at least when it is most important -- when making a decision as a member of a jury, but also when delineating the role of police officers in society.
Most white people would insist that there is a significant difference between the police and the Klu Klux Klan, because police are part of the formal, legal criminal justice system. But when police regularly act summarily, as an angry lawless white-hooded mob would, and with impunity, then the difference between the police and klansmen is one of degree, but not one of substance.
Lunch Links
Tuesday, September 22nd, 2009In Defense of the Police, He Does Have Two Arms
Monday, September 21st, 2009Cops taze wheelchair-bound double amputee.
Not an Onion story.
I feel like it is foam finger time again. USA! USA! USA!
Police taser unarmed, legless black man in a wheelchair
Monday, September 21st, 2009because they we're tasing a man in a wheelchair
and there was no reason for it.
-- A witness speaking on video with reporters.
Monday, September 21, 2009
Police taser unarmed, legless black man in a wheelchair
Black man said he was humiliated after his pants fell down during the incident. The officers allegedly left him outdoors in broad daylight, handcuffed on the pavement, nude below the waist. Williams said the Sept. 11 arrest also left him with an injured shoulder, limiting his mobility in his wheelchair.A handful of residents in Williams' apartment complex said they witnessed the incident and supported Williams' charges. A short video clip, shot by a neighbor and obtained by the Sun-Star, shows Williams sitting on the pavement with his pants down, his hands cuffed behind his back.
Hat Tip to Tasered While Black.
http://taseredwhileblack.blogspot.com/2009/09/police-taser-unarmed-legless-black-man.html
Police taser unarmed, legless black man in a wheelchair
Monday, September 21st, 2009A handful of residents in Williams' apartment complex said they witnessed the incident and supported Williams' charges. A short video clip, shot by a neighbor and obtained by the Sun-Star, shows Williams sitting on the pavement with his pants down, his hands cuffed behind his back.
http://taseredwhileblack.blogspot.com/2009/09/police-taser-unarmed-legless-black-man.html
His Aim Is True
Monday, September 21st, 2009A 14-year-old girl had to have a Taser dart removed from her skull after she was shot with the device by Tucumcari, New Mexico, Police Chief Roger Hatcher. Her mother, Stacy Atkins, says the two had been fighting over a cell phone and she took her daughter to the police station. The girl ran away, and Hatcher later found her at a park. When he approached her, she ran away, so he fired his Taser at her.
*This story originally misidentified the location of Tucumcari, New Mexico.
A simple question
Sunday, September 20th, 2009You see Donald Rumsfeld on the street. A man with a gun jumps Rumsfeld, apparently bent on killing him.
Who will you defend?
We’re probably all talking past each other, but this is a followup to “Why I am not specifically a voluntaryist“.
Related Blogs
- Related Blogs on Donald Rumsfeld
- Why hasn't there been any talk about impeachment of George W Bush …
- Related Blogs on vigilantism
- Vigilantism Is In This Year | Synthesis Weekly Serving Chico, CA …
- Video Vigilantism
Tags: Donald Rumsfeld, vigilantism
Related posts
Cheye Calvo in the Washington Post
Sunday, September 20th, 2009Berwyn Heights, Maryland Mayor Cheye Calvo has an op-ed in the Washington Post about his experience trying to get some accountability for the violent, mistaken 2008 raid on his home.
Let me give you three specific concerns underscored by our case.First, the Prince George’s Police Department’s internal affairs function is broken. When the Justice Department released the county police from federal supervision in February, internal affairs was the one area that was not cleared. Internal affairs division (IAD) investigations were required to take no longer than 90 days. More than a year after our ordeal, my family awaits the IAD report on what happened at our home. The statute of limitations for officer misconduct is 12 months, which means that any wrongdoers are off the hook.
Next, there is significant evidence that the county is broadly violating the Fourth Amendment, which protects against unreasonable search and seizure. After initially claiming that they had a “no-knock” warrant to forcibly enter our home, county police acknowledged that they did not have one. But they went on to contend that there is no such thing as a “no-knock” warrant in Maryland. But this isn’t true. A statewide “no-knock” warrant statute was passed in 2005. Effectively, the county is denying the existence of state law. We can’t get the county to say whether it has ever followed the law or, at a minimum, even acknowledges it.
Finally, and perhaps most disturbing of all, county police may be lying to cover up their civil rights violations. A county officer on the scene told Berwyn Heights police a fabricated tale to justify the warrantless entry into our home. The lie disappeared after police learned that I was the mayor. Charges of a police coverup are hardly unusual, but there is significant evidence that county law enforcement engaged in a conspiracy on our lawn to justify an illegal entry. Nothing strikes at the heart of police credibility like creative report writing and false testimony to cover up a lie or even put innocent people behind bars.
Calvo is really an impressive guy. I’ve never talked to him whether he’d ever consider running for higher office, but there’d be some poetic justice in seeing him become the next Prince George’s county executive.